2 lineups, many opinions. Please rate.

Manager Joined: May 03, 2004 Posts: 62

First of all, it's great to be back at Rotochamps for another awesome year. Secondly, I apologize for the long long post.

I am in two keeper leagues, one salary, one not. I was prepared for the salary draft, not for the normal one. Your opinions would be very appreciated and I will gladly give my unqualified two cents in return.

Salary league, 12 teams, strange stats, but fairly consistent with other leagues.

C- Piazza
1B - DLee
2B - BPhillips
3B - DWright
SS - Peralta
CI - ARam
MI - German (for now)
OF - Ichiro
OF - Kearns
OF - Rowand
OF - Willingham
B - Pods, EDukes

Pitchers:
Borowski
Capuano
Cook
CZambrano
Gordon
Izzy
MacDougal (we count holds as well)
Madson
Otsuka
BWilson
King Kelix
Igawa
Rogers
JShields
Vazquez
DL spot - Timlin

---------------------------------------------------

Keeper, serpentine league, 10 teams, 6x6 (OBP & SLG separate, and HLDs)

C - Piazza
1B - Pujols
2B - BPhillips
3B - Cabrera
SS - Felipe Lopez
MI - MYoung
RF - Sheff
CF - VWells
LF - Burrell
OF - DYoung
OF - CYoung
U - Rowand
B - Kinsler

SP - Jered Weaver
Mussina
Wang
Westbrook
Escobar
Contreras
Olsen
Jennings
RP - Nathan
Gordon
Jones
Borowski
Dempster
Rincon
MacDougal
Baez

Thanks again!

Posted: Tue Mar 27, 2007 12:15 pm

1st team:

Aaron Cook and Kenny Rogers do not belong on 12 team mixed league rosters. You're in trouble at 2B and SS. Who's available on the WW? Esteban German? He goes too. Your OF looks very weak. Dukes is a head case and I seriously doubt he contributes anything of value in TB this year.

Need Help- 2B, SS, OF, MI

Get rid of- Cook, Rogers, German, Dukes

2nd team:

Start Kinsler ahead of Phillips at 2B. Rowand is a terrible option at UT. There has to be something better on the WW, especially in a 10 team league. Do you have an IP limit for your pitching staff? You have a lot of pithcers, and some of them are not good. Wang lack's K's, and Jennings, Westbrook, and Contreras are average at best.

Need Help- UT

Get rid of- Rowand, excess pitching

Manager Joined: May 03, 2004 Posts: 62

Thanks slothinator.

I'm having all kinds of MI trouble this year...

With regard to team 2, there is a pitching limit but no one ever comes close to it. Teams in our league get in the habit of filling the regular P spots with relievers and rotating the starters in the SP spots.

Posted: Thu Mar 29, 2007 7:50 pm

slothinator wrote:

Dukes is a head case and I seriously doubt he contributes anything of value in TB this year.

ignore this person.

Posted: Thu Mar 29, 2007 9:27 pm

OPEC wrote:

slothinator wrote:

Dukes is a head case and I seriously doubt he contributes anything of value in TB this year.

ignore this person.

I missed the part where this is a keeper league. Dukes is worth hanging onto in this case.